Site icon The Anointed Writer

The Cost of Visibility in the AI Era

Online attention is the new currency for creators, but what drives that value on social networking platforms such as YouTube, Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok? When a viral video gets millions of views, does that mean that the content is valuable, or simply that it knows how to get your attention? These questions have become even more relevant as social media algorithms and generative artificial intelligence (AI) continue to influence how we create and consume content. My position is that engagement-optimised algorithms have created an environment that encourages sensationalism, outrage, and clickbait.  However, the outcomes are not inevitable. When used responsibly, these technologies can improve visibility without compromising authenticity and trust.

Social media platforms are designed to keep their users interested. YouTube, Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok use ranking and recommendation systems to determine what content people see, based on signals such as watch time, likes, shares, comments, and previous interactions. For example, TikTok’s recommendation system considers user interactions, video information, and individual account settings. Research by Boeker and Urman (2022) found that following accounts, liking content, and viewing behaviour influenced personalised recommendations. Meanwhile, Meta uses AI-powered predictions to rank content based on what users are likely to find relevant or engaging (Clegg, 2023). YouTube also considers viewing history, engagement, and audience satisfaction when recommending videos (YouTube, 2019).

Photo by Alex Knight on Pexels.com

How the platforms rank content suggests that the number of followers a brand or creator has does not determine the reach. A smaller creator may achieve significant visibility if their content resonates with an audience. While this creates opportunities, it also raises concerns about the types of content that receive the most attention. When engagement becomes a major indicator of success, there is temptation to create content that generates immediate reactions. This may include exaggerated headlines, controversial statements, misleading thumbnails, and content intended to provoke outrage.

Milli et al. (2025) found that engagement-based ranking on Twitter, now X, amplified emotionally charged and divisive political content compared with chronological ranking. Although this research focused on X, the findings raise important questions about the wider implications of prioritising engagement on social media. This is where engagement-driven algorithms become problematic. A post may generate thousands of comments and shares without providing meaningful value to its audience. In some instances, people may be engaging because they disagree with the information, find it offensive, or want to correct misinformation. A common misconception is that high engagement is equivalent to approval and credibility. I do not believe sensationalism is the only way to achieve reach. However, marketers and creators must recognise that the pressure to remain visible can influence their content decisions, sometimes at the expense of accuracy and authenticity.

Photo by Markus Winkler on Pexels.com

We have seen how quickly sensational content can spread in Jamaica, especially when it relates to matters of national interest.  During Jamaica’s 2025 General Election campaign, an AI-generated video circulated on social media, falsely depicting US President Donald Trump making allegations against Prime Minister Andrew Holness and discouraging Jamaicans from voting for him. According to Edwards (2025), the fabricated video was widely circulated, raising concerns about how misinformation could influence public opinion.

This example highlights how controversial and misleading content can attract attention, particularly when it involves public figures and politically sensitive issues. It also demonstrates the potential consequences of prioritising engagement over accuracy, especially when people depend on credible information to make important decisions. Thankfully, social media also presents genuine opportunities for Caribbean creators and small businesses.

In September 2026, The Gleaner featured Di Drool Factory, a Jamaican gourmet cookie business that gained greater visibility following a collaboration with content creator Tallonn Zeparti. According to the report, the collaboration went viral and helped the business attract customers beyond its immediate community (Manning, 2026). For me, these examples highlight two very different outcomes. While one demonstrates the risks associated with misleading content, the other shows how engaging, relevant content can create genuine business opportunities.

Generative AI is also changing how businesses approach social media marketing, making it easier and more affordable to create captions, images, and videos. This is particularly beneficial for small businesses with limited marketing budgets. However, while these tools improve efficiency, they also raise concerns about authenticity and trust. Brüns and Meißner (2024) found that AI-generated content can negatively affect consumers’ perceptions of brand authenticity, particularly when it replaces human creativity. For example, a restaurant using AI-generated images that do not accurately represent its meals may attract customers but ultimately damage their trust. I believe AI should support rather than replace human creativity. The responsibility remains with marketers to ensure that the content they produce is accurate, relatable, and consistent with the brand’s identity.

What’s interesting is how these generative AI tools operate in the Caribbean context. Do these systems adequately understand and represent Caribbean audiences? I have concerns about how well these systems understand Caribbean audiences. Our region is culturally diverse, with distinct languages, dialects, accents, traditions, and physical characteristics. However, the data used to train many AI systems may not adequately reflect this diversity. Language is one example. Jamaican Patois is an important part of our cultural identity, yet automated systems sometimes struggle to recognise and accurately interpret it.

Madden et al. (2025), in research examining automatic speech recognition and Jamaican Patois music, identified challenges with accurately transcribing the language. Consider a Jamaican content creator producing an educational video in Patois, only for the automated captions to misinterpret the message. Not only could this affect how the information is understood, but it could also limit accessibility for viewers who depend on subtitles. Representation in AI-generated imagery is another concern. Research has raised questions about whether AI systems adequately represent different skin tones. O’Malley et al. (2024), for example, proposed a methodology for evaluating skin-tone bias in AI-generated medical imagery. For Caribbean marketers, this highlights the importance of reviewing AI-generated visuals to ensure that they reflect the people, products, and communities being represented.

Geographical and regional factors may also influence content discovery. Boeker and Urman (2022) examined how location and language relate to TikTok recommendations. Although this does not establish that Caribbean creators are deliberately disadvantaged, it raises important questions about how audiences in smaller markets are represented and reached. I believe this is an area that requires greater attention. Caribbean creators should be able to produce content that reflects their identities without feeling pressured to abandon their dialects, accents, or cultural references to appeal to algorithms or AI systems. Technology should be able to adapt to the diversity of its users, rather than expecting users to change their identities to accommodate its limitations.

Photo by RDNE Stock project on Pexels.com

For small Caribbean businesses, I believe the focus should be on using these technologies strategically rather than trying to manipulate algorithms to achieve visibility. While reach and engagement are important, businesses should also consider whether their content is generating enquiries, sales and meaningful customer interactions. Equally important is ensuring that the content reflects the audiences being targeted. This means embracing local experiences, language and culture while using AI to support, rather than replace, creativity. Ultimately, businesses should prioritise building relationships and trust instead of relying solely on viral content to achieve success.

In closing, I do not believe sensationalism should be the price of visibility, nor should efficiency through AI come at the expense of trust. For Caribbean marketers, the opportunity lies in using these technologies to improve how we communicate while remaining true to the people and communities we represent.

Comparison of Original and AI-Generated Blog

Both blogs acknowledge the benefits of social media algorithms and generative AI while recognising the challenges they present for Caribbean marketers and content creators. However, my original blog takes a stronger position on how engagement-driven algorithms can encourage sensationalism and affect credibility. I also used actual Jamaican examples, including misinformation during the 2025 General Election and the growth of Di Drool Factory, to demonstrate both the negative and positive outcomes of social media visibility.

In comparison, the AI-generated blog takes a broader Caribbean approach, using hypothetical examples to explain how businesses across the region can benefit from these technologies. While both blogs address cultural representation and AI bias, I believe my original provides greater context on the implications for Jamaican creators, particularly regarding language and accessibility. The AI-generated version offers more detailed recommendations, but my original places greater emphasis on authenticity, accountability, and the importance of building trust rather than simply achieving reach.

Exit mobile version